Mr. Z's Pizza

Mr. Z's Pizza is a Key West pizza shop that earns its regulars through consistent quality and the kind of low-key approach that keeps the focus on the pie itself. In an island town full of novelty dining experiences, sometimes you just want a straightforward, satisfying pizza — and Mr. Z's delivers exactly that. It's a go-to for late-night hunger or a casual dinner when the tourist restaurants feel like too much. The menu stays in pizza territory, which is exactly the point, and the results are reliably good.